日本語・Markdown

Inhalation concentration and LFL / UFL

Safe inhalation concentrations

The safe concentration for inhaled molecular hydrogen depends on what is being measured. The classical handbook value applies to closed-system pre-mixed conditions; the value relevant to inhalation devices is the empirically measured one.

Where the 4% classical LFL applies

The chemistry handbook value for the lower flammability limit (LFL) of hydrogen — approximately 4% — was measured in closed pre-mixed mixtures at rest, for example inside a pipeline or sealed vessel. This is the figure used to set explosion thresholds in process engineering.

The 10% empirical inhalation-environment value

Inhaler operating conditions are different: atmospheric pressure, open system, continuous dilution, and a non-zero gas flow. The closed-system assumptions of the classical LFL no longer hold. Empirical measurements under realistic inhalation conditions place the safe operating ceiling at approximately 10%, supported by multiple experimental and case-based lines of evidence.

The UFL 75% paradox

Theoretically, hydrogen has an upper flammability limit (UFL) of approximately 75%: above that concentration, lack of oxidizer would prevent combustion. This argument is sometimes used to claim that 100%-pure-hydrogen output is intrinsically safe.

In practice:

  1. Boundary-layer concentration gradient: even at 100% output, a continuous concentration gradient forms between the outlet and ambient air, necessarily passing through the 4–75% flammable range.
  2. Mixing within the airway: nasal, tracheal, and pulmonary mixing with exhaled gas can transiently produce flammable compositions at local scale.
  3. Ubiquitous ignition sources: static electricity in the airflow and mucosal friction can act as low-energy ignition sources.
  4. UFL measurement conditions: the 75% figure assumes closed, pre-mixed, static gas. It does not apply directly to dynamic open systems.

The argument that "100% pure hydrogen output is intrinsically safe" therefore does not hold.

Operational recommendation

Cited papers

Cite as: H2 Papers — https://h2-papers.org/en/safety-notes/inhalation-concentration